← Incident Index
Protocol 3.2DevelopmentSENTINEL · AI-DEGRADED

PR Review Quality

Measures whether PRs receive substantive human reviews with comments, not just rubber-stamp approvals.

Reviews with real feedback catch bugs and spread knowledge. Auto-approvals with no discussion add process without value.

1publicly-documented incident in the Index where this protocol failedJSON →
Velocity Governance · Sentinel-10 Protocol

Protocol 3.2 is one of the 10 engineering practices Concordance flags as most degraded under AI-accelerated development. That 1 publicly-documented incident in this Index already failed it — before AI was the dominant velocity driver — is exactly the pattern the Velocity Governance thesis predicts will accelerate. Read the thesis →

Incidents that failed this protocol

OpenSSL ProjectApr 2014civilizational
CVE-2014-0160 — Heartbleed buffer over-read in OpenSSL TLS heartbeat
PR review quality: the original heartbeat patch (RFC 6520 implementation) merged with insufficient security review.
See where your repo scores against Protocol 3.2 — and the other 49 — in 60 seconds.
Run a free scan →Full framework →